Skip to main content

    The Insider Test

    Learn how to use The Insider Test to understand member mindsets, improve retention, and design a more relational community experience.

    Published
    26 September 2026

    The Insider Test is a qualitative diagnostic method used by community professionals to understand member mindsets. It differentiates between members who view their membership through a transactional 'customer' lens and those who hold a relational 'insider' perspective. The test is administered by asking members an open-ended question about the value they receive and then analysing the language they use in their response to reveal their underlying relationship with the organisation.

    Why it matters — The Insider Test

    Distinguishing between customer and insider mindsets is critical for building a resilient and engaged community. The balance between these two groups directly impacts retention, participation, and long-term strategic planning. Understanding this distinction allows community leaders to move beyond simplistic engagement metrics and diagnose the health of their community's social fabric.

    This is a preview. The full piece is free for members (3 reads a day) and unlimited with Premium.

    Read the full piece on Led by Community (free account, 3 reads a day)