When is a community pilot ready for a decision?

Review it at the agreed point or when a material change makes the original plan unsuitable. The evidence does not need to remove every uncertainty, but the decision should identify what is known, what remains unclear and the consequences of acting now.

Should a pilot continue if engagement is high?

High activity can indicate interest, but continuation also depends on relevance, customer experience and sustainable delivery. Examine who participated, what they gained and how much effort the service required. Activity alone does not establish that the programme should become permanent.

What if a pilot has too little evidence?

Identify the missing question and whether a bounded extension could answer it. Consider the resources and customer commitments that extension would require. If further work is unlikely to resolve the uncertainty, revising or closing the pilot may be more useful than repeating it.

Who should decide whether a community pilot continues?

The person accountable for the relevant programme commitment should decide with input from delivery owners and affected teams. Contributors provide evidence about feasibility, while customer feedback informs relevance. Make the decision authority explicit rather than assuming the person presenting the results controls every resource.

What belongs in a pilot decision record?

Record the original question, observed findings, limitations, selected option and reasons. Include the next service commitment, responsible owners, conditions and review point. Keep enough context to explain the choice later without requiring someone to reconstruct the entire pilot from meeting notes.

Turn a Community Experiment Into a Funding Decision

Decide whether to continue, change or stop a customer community pilot using evidence, delivery conditions and an explicit next commitment.

Published: 15 October 2026
Topics: Community strategy, Programme management

A community pilot should end with an explicit decision about the next commitment, supported by findings and delivery conditions. Compare what happened with the original question, identify what remains uncertain and assess whether the service can operate normally. Then choose continuation, revision or closure with named owners and a review point.

Launching a pilot creates momentum, but momentum is not a decision rule. Without a deliberate review, a temporary experiment can become a permanent service while its resources and customer promises remain unresolved.

Restate the decision the pilot was meant to inform

Begin with the original question in plain language. Perhaps the team wanted to learn whether an expert discussion series could help customer administrators resolve a recurring implementation difficulty. That question provides a different basis for review from a broad ambition to increase community engagement or build stronger relationships.

This is a preview. The full piece is free for members (3 reads a day) and unlimited with Premium.

Read the full piece on Led by Community (free account, 3 reads a day)